Q:

Any views on Vaccination - whether Painful or Painless one to give for a 6 week old baby? getting very diverse views.



Varsha Alange

this information might be useful for you:
Are there any studies to back up the claim that pain-free vaccines are not as effective and some doctors give boosters for all the vaccines given?

 

Yes. There have been a large number of studies mainly in the US and Australia because these were the two countries which saw resurgence of Pertussis or whooping cough in the late 2000. These studies reiterated the stand that the Wholecell vaccine is better and longer lasting. The World Health Organisation ( WHO) has also taken a position on this issue.

 

It is better to let the child’s natural immunity develop rather than administering vaccines?

 

Vaccines do not weaken the immunity system. Vaccination is not ready made protection against any disease. The child’s body produces antibodies to fight with the vaccine germs which help in fighting disease germs at the later stage when the child may come in contact with those diseases in future.

 

Is it true that human bodies need to react to the vaccine and only then it becomes effective?

 

No. Modern vaccines are highly purified vaccines. For instance, the vaccine against chicken pox now does not cause fever or pain and is highly effective. This is a very old concept.

 

Have pain-free vaccines been stopped because ``the stock is not good’’?

 

It is not a question of stock. Pain-free vaccines are not produced in India. They are always imported. The import, too, has now been stopped. But, it is a fact that the Western countries are still using pain-free vaccines.

 

Is the choice between pain-free and the “painful” vaccines dependent only on fever after vaccine has been administered?

 

It is not so. The pain and fever can be managed with simple medicines prescribed by the doctor. There is a certain amount of anxiety among parents but they need to look at the long term effect of the vaccine rather than the short term.

Roopashree Siddireddy

Painless injection are effective as wel. It's lil expensive or more they will charge. Many of my friends and me have given painless.

Dhara Popat

i have surfed net for the same and came to knw thru so. e of my friends too that painless vaccines are nt much effective and they r also banned at some places now.. its better to opt for painfull ones. i was also afraid befr first vaccination but now m nt.. its jus our fear.. u b strong in front of the baby.. keep your face smiling n calm.. baby understands our facial expressions... believe me my babies cries for nly few seconds after vaccinations and aftr tht they r jus fyn.. apply thrombophorbe if swelling comes or rub sme ice.. and give paracetamol drops as prescribed by the doc.. its jus two days and pain is gone.

Get the BabyChakra app
Ask an expert or a peer mom and find nearby childcare services on the go!
Phone
Scan QR Code
to open in App
Image http://app.babychakra.com/question/5287